The leasehold versus freehold decision is fundamental to buy-to-let investing, yet it's often overlooked in favor of more glamorous considerations like location or yield. Understanding tenure types affects everything from mortgage availability and ongoing costs to exit strategy and long-term capital appreciation.
In England and Wales, approximately 4.98 million properties are leasehold—around 20% of all housing stock. The vast majority of flats are leasehold, while most houses are freehold. For investors, choosing the right tenure type can mean the difference between a profitable investment and a problematic asset that's difficult to finance, manage, or sell.
Understanding Freehold and Leasehold
Freehold Ownership
Freehold ownership means you own the property and the land it stands on outright and in perpetuity. You have complete control over the property, subject only to planning laws and local regulations.
Key Characteristics of Freehold:
- Ownership is indefinite (no time limit)
- No ground rent or service charges (unless in a development with management company)
- Complete control over property modifications (subject to planning permission)
- Responsibility for all maintenance and repairs
- Easier to mortgage and typically more valuable
- No freeholder to seek permission from
Leasehold Ownership
Leasehold ownership means you own the property for a fixed period (the lease term), typically 99, 125, or 999 years when originally granted. The freeholder (also called the landlord) retains ownership of the land and the building's structure.
Key Characteristics of Leasehold:
- Time-limited ownership (lease term decreases annually)
- Ground rent payable to freeholder (typically £100-£500+ annually)
- Service charges for communal areas and building maintenance
- Restrictions on modifications and subletting (lease-dependent)
- May require freeholder permission for various activities
- Property value decreases as lease shortens
- Potential for lease extension or freehold purchase
Share of Freehold
A middle ground exists: share of freehold. Common in purpose-built blocks and converted houses, leaseholders collectively own the freehold through a company. Each flat owner holds shares in this company alongside their leasehold interest.
Advantages: Control over service charges and building decisions, no external freeholder extracting ground rent, ability to grant lease extensions at nominal cost.
Disadvantages: Still technically leasehold, requires collective decision-making, potential disputes with other shareholders, responsibility for building management.
Financial Implications for Buy-to-Let Investors
Purchase Price Differential
Leasehold properties typically sell at a discount compared to equivalent freehold properties, with the discount increasing as the lease shortens:
Ongoing Costs: Leasehold
Leasehold properties incur additional annual costs that directly impact net yield:
Ground Rent
Annual payment to the freeholder. Traditional leases: £100-£250/year. Modern leases (2000s-2010s): £250-£500/year, sometimes with doubling clauses. Post-2022 legislation bans ground rent on new leases, but existing leases remain unaffected.
Service Charges
Covers communal area maintenance, building insurance, management fees, and repairs to shared facilities. Typical range: £1,000-£3,000/year for flats, higher in premium developments with concierge, gym, or lift maintenance. Variable and can increase significantly over time.
Reserve Fund Contributions
Some developments require contributions to a sinking fund for major works (roof replacement, exterior redecoration). Typically £200-£500/year, but can be substantial in older buildings or those with deferred maintenance.
Permission Fees
Many leases require freeholder consent for subletting, alterations, or pet ownership. Consent fees typically £50-£200 per application, plus solicitor fees (£100-£300). Some freeholders charge annual subletting fees (£50-£150).
Major Works Charges
Leaseholders are liable for a proportionate share of major building works (roof repairs, exterior painting, lift replacement). These can be substantial—£5,000-£30,000+ per flat for significant works. Post-Grenfell cladding remediation has resulted in six-figure bills for some leaseholders.
Impact on Net Yield: Example Comparison
Freehold House
Purchase price: £200,000
Monthly rent: £950
Annual rental income: £11,400
Annual costs: £0 (ground rent/service charge)
Other costs: Buildings insurance £300
Gross yield: 5.7%
Net yield: 5.55%
Leasehold Flat
Purchase price: £180,000 (10% discount)
Monthly rent: £950 (same market rent)
Annual rental income: £11,400
Ground rent: £250
Service charge: £1,800
Gross yield: 6.33%
Net yield: 5.19%
Conclusion: Despite lower purchase price and higher gross yield, the leasehold flat delivers lower net yield due to ongoing costs. This 0.36% difference represents £648 annually—£6,480 over 10 years.
Calculate True Returns Including All Costs
BTL.properties factors in ground rent, service charges, and lease extension costs to show you real net yields before you buy.
Analyze a Property View PricingMortgage and Financing Considerations
Lender Requirements for Leasehold Properties
Mortgage lenders impose stricter criteria on leasehold properties:
Minimum Lease Term Requirements:
- Most lenders: Require 75-80+ years remaining at mortgage application
- Buy-to-let lenders: Often require 85+ years, sometimes 90+ years
- High-street lenders: Typically require lease extends 30-40 years beyond mortgage term
- Below 70 years: Very few lenders will offer mortgages, those that do charge premium rates
- Below 60 years: Effectively unmortgageable for most buyers
Ground Rent Restrictions
Since 2020, many lenders refuse to lend on leases with onerous ground rent terms:
- Doubling ground rents: Ground rent doubling every 10-25 years makes properties difficult to mortgage and sell
- High ground rent: Ground rent exceeding £250/year (£1,000 in London) can trigger additional lender restrictions
- Percentage-based ground rent: Ground rent linked to property value creates uncertainty and lender reluctance
- Uncapped increases: RPI-linked increases without caps concern lenders
Properties with problematic ground rent clauses may be unmortgageable, severely limiting your buyer pool when you sell.
Service Charge Considerations
Lenders assess service charges when calculating affordability:
- High service charges (£3,000+/year) reduce rental profit and may affect lending decisions
- Service charge arrears or disputes can prevent mortgage approval
- Buildings with Section 20 notices (major works pending) face lender reluctance
- Properties with EWS1 form issues (cladding concerns) may be unmortgageable
Lease Extension and Enfranchisement
When to Extend a Lease
The critical threshold is 80 years. Once a lease drops below 80 years remaining, leaseholders must pay "marriage value" (50% of the increase in property value resulting from the extension) in addition to the premium for extra years.
Key principle: Extend leases while above 80 years to avoid marriage value. A lease extension at 82 years costs significantly less than at 78 years, despite only four years' difference.
Statutory Lease Extension Process
Under the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, qualifying leaseholders can extend their lease by 90 years and reduce ground rent to zero (peppercorn rent).
Eligibility requirements:
- You must have owned the property for at least 2 years
- Original lease must have been granted for more than 21 years
- The building must contain at least two flats
- No more than 25% of the building can be commercial space
Lease Extension Costs
The total cost of a lease extension includes:
Total typical cost (above 80 years): £8,500-£21,800
Total typical cost (below 80 years): £18,500-£46,800+
Collective Enfranchisement (Freehold Purchase)
Leaseholders can collectively purchase the freehold of their building, provided at least 50% of flats participate and the building meets eligibility criteria. This allows complete control over management and the ability to grant lease extensions at minimal cost.
Typical costs: £3,000-£8,000 per flat for legal/valuation fees, plus the freehold purchase premium (£10,000-£30,000+ per flat depending on property values and lease terms).
Strategic Considerations for Buy-to-Let Investors
When Leasehold Makes Sense
Leasehold properties can be viable investments in specific circumstances:
Long Leases (125+ years)
With 125+ years remaining, lease depreciation is minimal (decades away from affecting value). If ground rent is reasonable (sub-£250) and service charges moderate (£1,500-£2,000), the property can deliver good returns. Priority markets: city centers where flats dominate and freehold alternatives are scarce.
Share of Freehold Properties
Share of freehold offers leasehold benefits (flat ownership) with freehold control. Service charges tend to be lower, as there's no profit-seeking freeholder. Ideal for small blocks (2-6 flats) where collective decisions are manageable. Can grant yourself lease extensions at cost.
Value-Add Opportunities
Properties with short leases (70-80 years) trading at significant discounts can offer value-add opportunities for sophisticated investors. Extend the lease immediately after purchase (factor 2-year ownership requirement), adding £20,000-£40,000 in value for £10,000-£20,000 cost. Requires capital reserves and understanding of process.
Central London and High-Value Markets
In prime central London, almost all flats are leasehold. If you want exposure to these markets, leasehold is unavoidable. Focus on properties with long leases, low ground rents, and well-managed buildings. Accept that service charges will be high (£3,000-£6,000+) but factor into yield calculations.
When to Prioritize Freehold
- Long-term hold strategy: If planning to hold 10+ years, freehold eliminates lease depreciation concerns
- Portfolio building: Freehold properties are easier to refinance and mortgage as portfolio grows
- Maximum control: If you want complete autonomy over property modifications and management
- Predictable costs: Freehold houses have more predictable expense profiles (no surprise service charges)
- Exit strategy: Freehold properties have broader buyer appeal, easier to sell quickly
- First-time landlords: Simpler to manage without freeholder complications
Red Flags: Leasehold Properties to Avoid
Avoid Properties With:
- Lease below 80 years (unless you have capital and expertise for immediate extension)
- Doubling ground rents (every 10-25 years)
- Ground rent above £500/year (£1,000 in London)
- Service charges above £4,000/year (unless rental income justifies it)
- Outstanding Section 20 major works notices
- Buildings with cladding issues or missing EWS1 forms
- Freeholders with reputation for excessive fees or poor management
- Lease clauses prohibiting subletting (check carefully)
- New-build leasehold houses (created 2010-2020, often with onerous terms)
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I rent out a leasehold property?
Usually yes, but many leases require freeholder consent for subletting. Check your lease carefully—some prohibit subletting entirely, others require written permission (with associated fees), and some allow subletting freely. Ensure subletting permission is confirmed before purchasing if you intend to let the property.
How does lease length affect capital growth?
Leases above 90 years experience minimal depreciation. Between 80-90 years, depreciation accelerates. Below 80 years, value drops significantly (10-30% compared to long leases). Below 70 years, properties become difficult to mortgage, severely limiting buyer pool and suppressing prices further. Capital appreciation is challenging with short leases.
What happens if I can't afford a service charge increase?
Service charge arrears can result in freeholder taking legal action, adding interest and legal fees to your debt, and ultimately forcing sale of your property. Leaseholders cannot opt out of service charges, though you can challenge unreasonable charges through the First-tier Tribunal. Always maintain reserves for service charge increases and unexpected major works.
Are new-build leasehold properties worth buying?
Exercise extreme caution. Many new-build leaseholds (especially houses built 2010-2020) have onerous terms including doubling ground rents, high service charges, and restrictive clauses. Since June 2022, new leasehold houses are banned (except exceptional circumstances), and ground rent on new leases is capped at £10/year. Pre-2022 properties may have problematic terms. Always have leases professionally reviewed before purchase.
Can I extend a lease before the 2-year ownership requirement?
You cannot use statutory rights until you've owned the property for 2 years. However, you can negotiate a voluntary lease extension with the freeholder at any time. Freeholders typically charge significantly more for voluntary extensions (lacking statutory process protection), but this may be worthwhile if you purchase with a very short lease and need to extend immediately for financing or sale purposes.
Is freehold always better than leasehold?
Not necessarily. In city centers and high-value areas, almost all flats are leasehold—you can't access these markets with a freehold-only strategy. Long leasehold flats (125+ years) with reasonable charges can deliver excellent returns. The key is understanding the specific lease terms, costs, and how they affect your investment returns. Analyze each opportunity on its merits rather than applying blanket rules.
Conclusion
The freehold versus leasehold decision is not binary. While freehold properties offer simplicity, control, and predictable costs, leasehold properties can deliver strong returns when purchased strategically with full understanding of the costs and restrictions involved.
Successful leasehold investing requires thorough due diligence: scrutinize lease terms, calculate all ongoing costs, verify lease length meets lender requirements, and assess service charge history. Factor lease extension costs into your acquisition analysis if the lease is below 90 years.
The upcoming Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act will make leasehold ownership easier (simplified lease extensions, capped ground rents on existing leases, enhanced rights), but fundamental principles remain: long leases, reasonable charges, and well-managed buildings are essential for successful leasehold investment. When in doubt, seek professional legal and surveying advice before committing capital.
Analyze Freehold and Leasehold Investments
Compare true net yields with all costs included before making your investment decision.
Start Your Analysis